How to Counter a Lowball Salary Offer (with Scripts You Can Steal)
That first number is a starting point, not a ceiling. Here's the exact framework — and word-for-word scripts — to counter without burning the offer.
You got the offer. It's lower than you wanted. Now what?
Most people do one of two things: (1) accept it because they're afraid of losing the offer, or (2) counter awkwardly and either overshoot or undersell. Both cost you real money — often $10K-$50K over a two-year tenure.
There's a third move. It's confident, it's specific, and it works in about 75% of cases where there's ANY room in the band. Here's the play.
Bold career takes — while you read, watch this classic keynote for the mindset.
Step 1 — Never accept on the phone
The moment they say the number, do NOT react. Not with excitement, not with disappointment. Say this exactly:
'Thanks for the offer — I'm genuinely excited about the role. Can you send this over in writing so I can review the full package and get back to you within 48 hours?'
That single sentence buys you time, signals professionalism, and starts the negotiation from a position of consideration — not desperation.
Step 2 — Anchor with data
Before you counter, know the market. Levels.fyi, Glassdoor, Payscale, and LinkedIn Salary give you 25th / 50th / 75th percentile numbers for your exact role, level, and city. If you're being offered at or below the 50th, you have room. If you're offered above the 75th, you're already winning — negotiate perks instead of base.
Step 3 — The counter script
Send this in email. Not a phone call. Written counters are calmer, harder to dismiss, and give both sides time to think.
'Thanks again for the offer. I'm ready to move forward — I just want to align on comp before I sign. Based on market data for [role] at [level] in [city], the range I've been seeing is $X - $Y. Given [1-2 specific things you bring], I'd like to land at $Z. If we can get to that number, I'm ready to accept today.'
Step 4 — Handle the pushback
They may come back with 'this is our final offer' or 'we don't have room in the band.' Here's the counter-counter:
'Understood — if base isn't flexible, could we look at signing bonus, equity refresh, or an earlier performance review at 6 months?'
Everything is a negotiation. Even in a 'fixed' offer, there's almost always room in one of these levers.
What NOT to do
- ▸Don't apologize for negotiating. Every hiring manager expects it.
- ▸Don't threaten to walk unless you actually will. Bluffing on your only offer is career suicide.
- ▸Don't ask for a huge jump without evidence. Anchor with numbers, not feelings.
- ▸Don't negotiate against yourself ('I could do $80K, or maybe $75K, whatever works…'). Give ONE number.
The bottom line
You don't get what you're worth. You get what you negotiate. A five-minute email — sent with confidence and backed by data — is often the highest hourly-rate work of your entire career. Send it.
Get playbooks like this in your inbox.
Weekly resume rewrites, salary scripts, and job-hunt playbooks. No fluff.
No spam. Unsubscribe with one click.
